In other offseason news: "The Yankees offered arbitration to left-hander Al Leiter and right-hander Ramiro Mendoza, extending the negotiating window with the two free agent pitchers. The club. . . declined to offer arbitration to eight other free agents, effectively severing ties with Kevin Brown, Alan Embree, Matt Lawton, John Flaherty, Tino Martinez, Rey Sanchez, Felix Rodriguez and Ruben Sierra." [MLB.com]
Kevin Brown made 22 starts for the Yankees in 2004 with a 10-6 record and a 4.09 ERA. In 2005 he only made 13 starts, with a record of 4-7 and a 6.51 ERA. [Stats from ESPN.com] This begs the question: Did the team make the right decision trading for him? And even if the answer to that is yes (based on what the players we traded for him have done in the intervening time -- see below), it also begs the question whether we should've made the trade for Jeff Weaver (who was traded for Brown).
We traded Jeff Weaver, along with Yhency Brazoban and Brandon Weeden, to get Brown in the offseason between the 2003 and 2004 seasons. That probably wasn't a bad move, considering Weaver had been pretty ineffective for us, despite all the potential people believed he had. Weaver went 14-11 with a 4.22 ERA for the Dodgers in 2005, but he might not be re-signed for 2006. He's 27-24 in the last two seasons, making 34 starts each of those seasons. Brazoban is developing into a setup man for the Dodgers. 2005 was his first season and he posted a record of 4-10, 21 saves, 5.33 ERA. Weeden is still in the minors. [Stats from ESPN.com] So, Weaver hasn't been a blazing ball of fire (and there's no guarantees he'd have had similar numbers for the Yankees), but he did make 68 starts versus Brown's 35. Worth isn't measured just in wins -- having someone durable to make a lot of starts would've really helped the Yankees this past season.
We'd traded for Weaver midseason 2002 in exchange for Ted Lilly and John-Ford Griffin and Jason Arnold. Lilly is 36-32 in major league starts since leaving the Yankees; his ERA was around 4.00 in 2003-2004, but went up in 2005 to 5.56. Griffin played in seven games this past season, hitting .308 with one homer and six RBI. Arnold is still in the minors.
What do you think? Just for the sake of argument, would the Yankees have been better off if they'd kept Weaver, et al and not traded for Brown? Would the Yankees have been better off if they'd kept Lilly, et al and not traded for Weaver?